Paper 1.4
AN
EXAMINATION OF THE AMS/INDUSTRY MINORITY SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM
Kathryn Ginger* UCAR/PAGE, Boulder, CO
Stephanie Armstrong, AMS, Boston, MA
Betsy Abrams, The Weather Channel, Atlanta, GA
*Corresponding
author address: Kathryn M. Ginger, UCAR/PAGE, P.O. Box
3000, Boulder, CO 80307; ginger@ucar.edu
download accompanying Power Point presentation
1. INTRODUCTION
Since 1993
The American Meteorological Society (AMS) has conducted an
undergraduate, minority industry scholarship program. The
scholarships are awarded to high school seniors entering their
freshman year of college, pursuing degrees in the atmospheric
and related oceanic and hydrologic sciences. During these
past seven years, 33 scholarships have been awarded. As a
result, there are scholarship winners at the following different
levels:
- New winners who will use their
scholarships during the fall of 1999 (9 students)
- Previous winners still working
on their undergraduate degrees (15 students)
- Previous winners who have
completed their degree and may be employed or pursuing a
graduate degree (7 students)
- Previous winners who did not
complete their undergraduate degrees (2 students)
With this
history, the efficacy and effectiveness of the AMS scholarship
program will be examined using data collected by the AMS during
phone interviews and questionnaires with scholarship recipients.
Essentially, is this program encouraging and retaining under-represented
groups in the atmospheric and related oceanic and hydrological
sciences?
2. SCHOLARSHIP
PROGRAM DESCRIPTION
The AMS/Industry
Minority Scholarship program is intended to encourage minority students who
have been traditionally underrepresented in the sciences,
especially Hispanic, Native American, and Black/African American
students. Currently for fall 1999, there are nine scholarships
funded by three different sources:
- Donations from society
members who wish to support AMS Programs in Support of Science
and Education (3 scholarships)
- Industry: The Weather
Channel®, Litton PRC Inc., Computer Sciences Corporation
(CSC) and Raytheon Santa Barbara Remote Sensing (4 scholarships)
- Government: National
Environmental Satellite, Data and Information Service (NESDIS)
(2 scholarships)
The award
is $3000 for a nine-month period in the freshman year and
an additional $3000 for a nine-month period in the sophomore
year, based on performance in the first year.
3. RECENT
PROGRAM STATISTICS
This year’s
class of 9 scholarship winners is just over one-quarter of
the total 33 winners. This illustrates growth in the number
of scholarships and the applicant pool. In fact the NESDIS
scholarships are new for this school year and the number of
applicants for the years 1997-99 was 95. Compare this to two
scholarships for the 1993-1994 academic year and total number
of 202 applicants for 1993-1999. Thus, there has been a shift
in the applicant pool since the beginning of the program.
Over the last few years, the applicant pool has almost doubled
and nearly all applicants demonstrated with indicated major,
choice of schools and essay clear intent to enter into a degree
program in the atmospheric and related oceanic and hydrologic
sciences (see Table 1).
Table 1: 1997-1999
Indicated Majors
Major |
Applicants |
Recipients |
Atmos. Sci |
36 |
14 |
Math |
1 |
0 |
Physics |
2 |
1 |
Engineering |
15 |
0 |
Science |
30 |
4 |
Other |
11 |
2 |
For 1998
and 1999, winners indicated they would be attending some of
the following schools: Stanford, University of Oklahoma, Brown,
Texas A&M, Florida State University, MIT, Ohio University,
University of CA at San Diego, University of Virginia.
As with any
program, there is start-up and growth time. The AMS minority
industry scholarship program appears to be in the growth phase.
4. SCHOLARSHIP
PROGRAM HISTORY
The AMS Industry
Minority Scholarship Program began in 1993 with the awarding
of two scholarships. Through 1995, the program was funded
solely with contributions by members to the AMS 75th Anniversary Campaign. In 1996, the AMS was joined by industry
and continued to support three scholarships with contributions
by members the AMS Programs in Support of Science and Education.
In 1996, The Weather Channel joined in sponsoring a new scholarship.
In 1997, PRC joined with another scholarship while in 1998
Computer Science Corporation and Raytheon Santa Barbara Remote
Sensing joined with two additional awards. The government
agency, NESDIS, joined this year with 2 scholarship bringing
the total number to 9.
5. APPLICANT
AND RECIPIENT HISTORY
To update
the status of scholarship participants, the AMS mailed a questionnaire
and conducted follow-up emails and phone calls. Only 5 of
the 33 recipients responded to the questionnaire and two additional
awardees responded later to emails and phone calls. The poor
response rate is probably du to the fact that winners are
under no obligation to remain in contact with the AMS after
their sophomore year when they no longer receive funds.
The questionnaire
asked scholarship recipients list the following:
- Current situation whether
studying in or outside the atmospheric and related sciences
field
- University and major or employer’s
name
- Current research interests
and publications
- How has the AMS minority scholarship
helped you?
For the open-ended
question about how the scholarship has helped you, the following
responses were received. A student at Darmouth College majoring
in computer science said the scholarship "has greatly
helped to close the gap towards the education he is receiving."
He plans to use his programming skills toward a career in
the atmospheric sciences with regard to modeling. There are
three other students who veered off the science path. No explanation
for their choices was provided in the collected data. One
student has become a financial consultant while the other
two have discontinued their studies at this time.
During the
scholarship period of the last seven years the break down
by major is as follows:
1993-1994:
2 recipients (1 status unknown, 1 financial consultant)
1994-1995:
3 recipients (1 discontinued studies, 2 status unknown)
1995-1996:
3 recipients (3 status unknown)
1996-1997:
4 recipients (fall 1999 seniors)
- 1 marine science major
- 1 earth/environmental science
- 1 meteorology major
- 1 environmental/atmos. science
major/li>
1997-1998:
5 (fall 1999 juniors)
- 5 meteorology/atmos. science
majors
1998-1999:
7 recipients (fall 1999 sophomores)
- 2 meteorology majors
- 1 environmental science major
- 1 chemistry
- 1 hydrology
- 1 physics
- 1 discontinued studies
1999-2000:
9 recipients (freshman in fall 1999)
- 7 meteorology/atmos. science
majors
- 2 environmental science majors
From this list,
most students, 24 of 33 (73%) are participating in atmospheric
science or science while 3 out of 33 (9%) have either left
science or discontinued their studies. The six students (18%)
with unknown status may or may not be in science.
Table 2 shows
the breakdown of recipients by ethnic group. Black/African
Americans are the predominant ethnic group represented.
Table 2: Recipient
Ethnicity
Ethnicity |
# |
Black/African
American |
12 |
Asian or
Pacific Islander |
6 |
Hispanic |
9 |
American
Indian/Alaskan Native |
6 |
When the
AMS and the University Corporation for Atmospheric Research
(UCAR) publish the new Curricula 2000 in the Atmospheric
and Oceanic, Hydrologic and Related Sciences, the scholarship
winners of the last few years could represent a sizable percentage
of the total number of minorities that are listed as current
majors.
Table 3 shows
the breakdown by gender for recipients.
Table 3: Gender
of Recipients
Year |
Males |
Females |
1993 |
1 |
1 |
1994 |
1 |
2 |
1995 |
2 |
2 |
1996 |
2 |
2 |
1997 |
4 |
1 |
1998 |
3 |
4 |
1999 |
4 |
5 |
The number
of female recipients is equal to or greater than the number
of male recipients for every year except 1998. Recipients
also represent 17 states and the District of Columbia with
Texas, California, New York, Florida, Oklahoma, North Carolina,
Virginia, New Jersey and Kansas having multiple scholarship
winners.
6. CONCLUSION
While it
appears the AMS Industry Minority Scholarship has entered
a growth phase based on the number of applicants and their
indicated major, it is difficult to judge how this program
is meeting the needs of these students. While one student
said the program has helped him meet his educational goals,
the lack of response from other scholarship winners in updating
their information does not indicate either a negative or positive
influence on the scholarship program. Hopefully, as the number
of scholarship winners becomes more numerous and the fact
that the AMS publishes yearly updates of scholarship winners,
awardees will be inclined to share their status with the Society.
To see how
mainstream the information is on the scholarship program,
it is nice to see that when conducting a search with several
different web search engines, the AMS awards program is listed
and it is listed on several known scholarship web pages. The
minority program is also listed on a scholarship based on
ethnicity web page. Because the program has existed for seven
years it is also receiving good support from high school counselors
and educators. Therefore, using the last few years as a rough
guide, one can probably expect the AMS to have more applications
in the future for this worthy endeavor.
|